no fees unless we win
Si Hablamos Espanol

New City Personal Injury Lawyer

Your Advocate in New City
  • Hundreds
    of millions of dollars recovered
  • Thousands
    of cases won
  • 100+
    years of combined experience
  • 40+
    years serving clients
Three middle-aged men wearing business suits and ties standing closely together, smiling.

Maximum Results. Minimal Stress.

Municipal Liability
$8,365,000
Settlement for Municipal Liability

A 17-year-old girl's life changed forever on the Van Wyck expressway in Queens when ice accumulation caused their vehicle to skid up an underpass. Record-breaking evidence proved the city and state had ignored this hazardous condition for years.

Birth Injury
$8,000,000
Settlement for Birth Injury

A New York couple's infant suffered profound brain damage during delivery. Expert testimony revealed critical obstetrical errors by the hospital staff, securing the child's future medical needs.

Birth Injury
$4,000,000
Settlement for Birth Injury Negligence

In Orange County, an obstetrician's excessive force during childbirth stretched nerves in the baby's right arm. Despite claims that injury was a normal risk, evidence proved improper delivery technique caused Erb's palsy.

Medical Malpractice
$2,885,000
Settlement for Victim of Surgical Error

A surgeon's unnecessary nerve biopsy during routine back pain surgery led to below-knee amputation. Expert testimony disproved the doctor's tumor suspicions, securing compensation for the patient's life-changing injuries.

Construction Accidents
$2,500,000
Fatal Construction Accident

A tragic elevator shaft collapse at a Brooklyn construction site claimed the life of a 61-year-old worker. By proving the site's violation of New York Labor Law, his family received a measure of justice.

‍

Auto Accident
$2,250,000
Settlement for Pedestrian Accident

A woman's peaceful Sunday walk in their local neighborhood ended tragically when a newly licensed driver struck her. Insurance limits were quickly secured after proving clear liability.

Get a Free Consultation

Experienced New City Personal Injury Lawyers

A serious injury can change your life in a moment. If someone else’s negligence caused it, you shouldn’t have to face the next steps alone.

If you need a personal injury lawyer in New City, NY, Fellows Hymowitz Rice has stood by injured people here since 1981. We help people hurt in truck crashes, serious car accidents, construction accidents (New York State Labor Law 200, 240 and 241(6), pedestrian accidents, slip, trip and fall accidents, snow and ice accidents, bicycle accidents, nursing home negligence, and wrongful death. If you or a loved one was hurt, call (845) 639-9300 or message us online for a free consultation.

‍

a group of men sitting around a table talking

Get Legal Help Now

Let our experienced team fight for you. Get in touch with us today for a free consultation and get the legal advice you deserve!

Free consultation
Call Us Now
(845) 639-9300

Legal Services We Provide

A Personal Injury Lawyer for Life-Changing Cases in New City, NY

If you were hurt in New City, whether you live here or were just passing through, we can help. If your injury left you with permanent harm, high medical bills, or the loss of a family member, we take on the investigation and the insurance fight so you can put your energy into healing.

These are the cases where having a lawyer usually matters most:

  • Truck accidents. Our truck accident lawyers move fast to secure driver logs and electronic data before carriers can lose or overwrite them.
  • Construction accidents. Our construction accident team handles all types of work related injuries, including ladder accidents, scaffold accidents, falling objects, dangerous tools, excavation and demolition accidents and more under what is commonly called New York State Labor Law 200, 240 and 241(6) 
  • Serious car accidents. Our car accident team proves your injuries are serious enough under New York law to seek full compensation.
  • Wrongful death. We help families get court approval to act for their loved one and meet filing deadlines while pursuing wrongful death claims on their behalf.
  • Pedestrian accidents. If a driver hit you while you were walking, we go after the driver’s insurance for losses your own coverage won’t pay.
  • Slip, trip, and fall injuries. We hold property owners responsible for dangerous conditions they should have fixed like broken sidewalks and snow and ice. 
  • Nursing home negligence. If your parent or loved one was hurt by a fall, bedsores, or neglect in a care facility, we help your family hold the facility accountable.

If your injury doesn’t fit neatly on this list (like a dog bite for example), call anyway. We will tell you whether we can help or point you toward someone who can.

Where Will Your New City Injury Case Be Heard?

Injury lawsuits from crashes and falls in New City are generally filed in the Supreme Court at the county courthouse at 1 South Main Street. Our office is a few blocks away at 254 South Main Street, so our attorneys know this courthouse, its procedures, and its judges’ expectations from years of practice there.

Crashes on the Roads New City Residents Use Every Day

Many of our motor vehicle cases begin on the routes New City residents drive daily, including South Main Street through the hamlet’s center, New Hempstead Road, Route 59 and Route 304.

Claims Against a Town, Village, or the County

If a government body caused your injury, such as a town that ignored a broken sidewalk, the rules are stricter and the deadlines are shorter, as explained in the deadlines section below. New City is part of the Town of Clarkstown, and we handle claims against the town, the county, and other public agencies.

Who Will Handle Your Case at Fellows Hymowitz Rice?

Your case is handled by attorneys who have built their careers and reputations right here in New City. Founding and managing partner Rob Fellows has practiced law for more than 40 years and served as president of the Rockland County Bar Association from 2022 to 2024. 

Rob Fellows’s Roots in Our Community

Rob’s work in the community goes beyond the courtroom. He received the County of Rockland Distinguished Service Award in 2023, sits on the Rockland County Bar Association’s board of directors, and has been selected to Super Lawyers every year since 2013.

The Partners Behind Every Case 

Rob works alongside partners Steve Hymowitz and Matthew Rice. All three were named 2026 Top Lawyers by Hudson Valley Magazine and all three are SuperLawyers. All three are AV rated by Martindale-Hubbell and hold perfect 5.0 ratings with Avvo. Steve Hymowitz is a premier medical malpractice litigator having secured millions and millions of dollars in recoveries. Matthew Rice is a member of the Million Dollar Advocates forum and holds a JD-MBA. He also has decades of defense industry experience that he now leverages for our clients into the maximum possible settlements knowing every trick and tactic the insurance companies employ. He specializes in high-stakes construction accidents and municipal litigation, having secured one of the highest settlements ever against the City and State of New York for a paralyzed woman for $8,650,000. 

‍

How Do We Build a Personal Injury Claim in New York?

We start by finding out what happened and who is responsible, then we document every way the injury has affected your life. From there, we deal with insurers on your behalf and prepare each case as though it may go to trial, because insurers make better offers when they know we are ready.

The table below shows what we do first in several common case types:

Case Type What We Do First (Sample List)
Truck accident Send letters requiring the trucking company to save its driver logs, onboard computer data, and maintenance records
Car accident Document how your injuries meet New York’s serious injury threshold so you can pursue more than no-fault benefits
Fall on private property Photograph the hazard, identify witnesses, and request surveillance video before it is recorded over
Injury involving a town or the county File the written notice the town must receive within 90 days
Nursing home negligence Request the resident’s chart, care plan, and incident reports

Once those first steps are done, we gather your medical records and proof of lost pay and future costs, and we keep you informed as your claim moves forward.

The Deadlines We Watch for You

New York generally gives you three years from the date of injury to file a negligence lawsuit under CPLR 214. Claims against a town, village, county, or other public body usually require a written notice of claim within 90 days under General Municipal Law § 50-e. Exceptions can shorten or extend these periods, so the safest step is to call us early.

Car Crash Claims and the Serious Injury Rule

Car accident cases follow an extra rule. New York’s no-fault system pays basic medical bills and lost wages, and you can sue the at-fault driver for pain and suffering only if your injury meets the serious injury threshold, such as a fracture or a significant limitation of a body function.

A person holding his neck after a car accident

What Shapes the Result of a Personal Injury Case?

No honest lawyer can promise a number, and we won’t. What we can do is show you which factors will matter in your case and build the strongest record possible on each one.

The Factors We Focus On

How badly you were hurt, how clear it is who caused the accident, and how much insurance is available all affect what your claim can recover. New York cuts a recovery by your share of fault, and in car cases being more at fault than the other side bars it, so we answer insurers’ blame-shifting.

Results for Our Neighbors

Here are a few results we have obtained for clients in communities near New City:

  • $850,000 settlement for an elderly couple who suffered fractures when a car pulling out of a driveway struck their vehicle on Route 202 in Suffern.
  • $455,000 for a woman left with permanent skin damage after a West Nyack salon negligently applied perm chemicals.
  • $300,000 after a jury found negligence in a nursing home where a resident recovering from surgery fell from her bed and fractured her hip.

Each case depends on its own facts, and prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Why Injured People in New City Choose Us

At Fellows Hymowitz Rice, we live and work in New City, and we treat you the way we’d want our own families treated.

Here is what you can expect when you hire us:

  • Direct access to your attorney. You will know who is handling your case and how to reach them.
  • Help in English and Spanish. Our team includes Spanish-speaking staff, and we can meet you at home, in the hospital, or at a rehabilitation center.
  • Local knowledge that protects your claim. We know New City’s roads, the Town of Clarkstown’s notice rules, and the county courts, so local deadlines and requirements don’t get missed.
  • Help with the paperwork. We handle the no-fault forms, medical records requests, and insurance letters so you can focus on getting better.
  • No fee unless we win. You pay no attorney’s fee unless we recover compensation for you.
  • Client Reviews. The firm has received over 300 5-Star Google Reviews for a 5.0 rating.  

Ready to talk? Call (845) 639-9300 or contact us online.

Injured? Our New City Attorneys Answer Your Questions

These are common questions people ask us before hiring a personal injury attorney in New City, NY.

Talk With a New City Personal Injury Attorney Today

Recovering from an injury is hard enough without worrying about bills, insurance, and what comes next. The attorneys at Fellows Hymowitz Rice will review your situation and explain your options in plain terms, so you can make your next decision with confidence.

Call (845) 639-9300 any time, day or night, or fill out our contact form for a free consultation. We’re ready to help.

Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar future outcome.

‍

Why Choose Us for Your New City Personal Injury Claim?

At Fellows Hymowitz Rice, we understand that facing an injury is a difficult and overwhelming experience. That's why we're here — to provide you with strong legal representation and unwavering support during this challenging time. We're not just lawyers; we're your partners in pursuit of justice. Here are the key strong points of our law firm that will help us win your case:

  • We Listen, We Understand

    We know that being injured is more than just physical pain; it impacts your entire life. That's why we start with a free consultation where we listen to your story, answer your questions, and provide honest and compassionate guidance about your legal options.

  • We Leave No Stone Unturned

    Our team goes beyond just reviewing your case. We conduct thorough investigations, gather evidence, and even consult with experts to build a strong case that highlights your injuries and losses. We fight for every dollar you deserve.

  • We Negotiate with Confidence

    We've recovered over $100 million for our clients, and we're not afraid to take on insurance companies to ensure you get a fair settlement. We'll aggressively negotiate on your behalf, using our experience and legal skills to protect your rights.

  • We Stand By Your Side

    You're not alone in this journey. We'll keep you updated throughout your case, explaining complex legal matters in plain language so you feel informed and empowered. We're your voice and your advocate, fighting for the justice you deserve.

  • We're Ready When You Are

    Don't let an accident define your future. Contact Fellows Hymowitz Rice today for a free consultation. We're here to help you move forward — stronger than before.

Meet Our Attorneys

Injured in New City, Rockland County? Let us help you seek justice. Contact us today!

  • smiling man in suit and tie with a blue tie
    Partner
    Robert L. Fellows

    Rob Fellows is more than just a lawyer; he's a seasoned advocate and a respected leader in the legal community. With over 40 years of experience, he's earned a reputation for meticulous preparation, unwavering advocacy, and a genuine commitment to his clients. 

    • 2026-Personal-Injury-Seal
    • Super Lawyers badge indicating Robert L. Fellows has been rated for 10 years.
    • a blue and white badge with the words top attorney
    • the logo for public justice impact change
    • an image of a judge and a scale of justice
    • a black and white photo of the statue of liberty
    • AV Preeminent badge indicating peer rating for highest level of professional excellence in 2026.
    • Martindale-Hubbell Client Champion Gold 2026 badge with a hexagon and chain link logo.
    View Robert’s Bio
  • undefined
    Partner
    STEVEN R. HYMOWITZ

    Steve Hymowitz is a champion for the underdog, specializing in medical malpractice and construction accident cases. He’s known for his warmth and unwavering dedication, relentlessly pursuing justice for those who feel powerless against insurance companies.

    • 2026-Personal-Injury-Seal
    • Badge stating Steven R. Hymowitz is rated by Super Lawyers with 10 years of recognition.
    • a blue and white badge that says avvo ratings
    • an image of a judge and a scale of justice
    • a black and white photo of the statue of liberty
    • a red and black label with a white background
    View Steven’s Bio
  • man in a suit and tie posing for a picture
    Partner
    MATTHEW F. RICE

    Matthew brings an unparalleled level of energy and drive to every case, earning a reputation for achieving exceptional results. He goes beyond financial wins, building deep connections with clients and becoming a trusted advisor during their most difficult times.

    • 2026-Personal-Injury-Seal
    • an image of a judge and a scale of justice
    • a black and white photo of the statue of liberty
    • a blue and white badge that says avvo ratings
    • the logo for public justice impact change
    • a red and black label with a white background
    View Matthew’s Bio
  • a woman wearing a black suit and white shirt
    Lawyer
    JOANNE R. HOROWITZ

    Joanne Horowitz is a skilled legal strategist and a strong advocate for those facing injuries due to negligence, construction accidents, and medical malpractice.

    View Joanne’s Bio
  • Lawyer
    Margaret Porcelli

    Margaret is a seasoned negotiator, expert in civil dispute resolution, with extensive experience handling homicide cases.

    View Margaret’s Bio
  • Portrait of a bald man with a beard wearing a navy blue suit, white shirt, and gold tie.
    Lawyer
    Jake Yelin

    Jake is a dedicated, hardworking, and compassionate attorney with a unique perspective shaped by his experience representing both plaintiffs and defendants.

    View Jake’s Bio

Featured Reviews

Areas We Serve in New York State

We represent clients across New York State, from the streets of Manhattan to the communities of Rockland, Westchester, and beyond. Get the legal help you need wherever you are.

Map of New York counties including Greene, Columbia, Ulster, Dutchess, Sullivan, Orange, Putnam, Westchester, Rockland, Suffolk, Nassau, Queens, Kings, Richmond, Bronx, and New York.

Get a Free Consultation Today

Focus on healing, and we'll handle the legal details. Call or contact us online for a free consultation, and let's discuss your options.

Thank you!
Your message has been submitted
Choose Practice Area

You will receive a response from us within 1 - 2 business days

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
a view of a city skyline at night