Rob Fellows is a renowned personal injury attorney with over 40 years of experience. As managing partner at Fellows Hymowitz Rice, he is known for his meticulous preparation and aggressive advocacy in the courtroom.
When winter weather transforms New York sidewalks and parking lots into treacherous ice sheets, property owners bear a legal responsibility to maintain safe conditions. If you've suffered injuries from slipping on ice due to another party's negligence, understanding your legal options becomes essential for protecting your rights and securing fair compensation.
At Fellows Hymowitz Rice, our New City slip and fall lawyers have successfully represented clients injured in ice-related accidents throughout New York State. We understand the complex intersection of premises liability law, municipal regulations, and insurance claims that govern these cases, and we're committed to helping injured victims win maximum compensation for their injuries.
New York Law on Property Owner Duties for Ice and Snow
New York law imposes a duty on property owners to maintain their premises in a reasonably safe condition for visitors and pedestrians. This obligation extends to winter hazards like snow and ice. When a property owner fails to act within a reasonable time, they may be held liable for resulting injuries.
The Legal Foundation of Your Claim
To win a personal injury lawsuit, the injured party must show that the property owner was liable because they breached their duty of care. In these cases, liability often turns on whether the property owner failed to remedy or warn of the hazard in time. Many claims are also negotiated through the owner’s liability insurance or defended by their insurance company.
The concept of "notice" proves critical in ice-related cases. Property owners can be held liable if they created the dangerous condition or had actual or constructive notice of its existence with sufficient time to remedy it.
New York City's Specific Snow Removal Requirements
In New York City, the Administrative Code §16-123 establishes precise timelines for snow and ice removal that effectively define when a property owner has constructive notice:
These requirements include clearing a path at least four feet wide, maintaining access to crosswalks and pedestrian ramps at corner properties, and spreading salt, sand, or similar materials when the ground remains frozen. Violations of these specific deadlines provide powerful evidence of negligence in slip and fall cases.
What Compensation Can You Recover?
If you’re an injured party in an ice-related accident, your personal injury lawsuit may seek compensation from the property owner’s liability insurance. Settlements typically depend on medical expenses, lost wages, and the extent to which the property owner was liable for your fall.
Economic Damages
- Medical expenses: Full reimbursement for past, current, and future treatment costs.
- Lost wages: Compensation for all missed income, benefits, and retirement contributions.
- Reduced earning capacity: Payment for long-term or permanent disability affecting future income.
Average settlement amounts for serious slip and fall injuries in New York vary significantly based on injury severity. You can learn more about these figures and the factors that drive higher payouts in our analysis of typical slip and fall settlements across NYC.
Non-Economic Damages
These subjective losses, while harder to quantify, often exceed economic damages in value.
Common types include:
- Pain and suffering: Compensation for physical pain and emotional distress.
- Loss of enjoyment of life: Recognition that injuries limit hobbies, social activities, and daily pleasures.
- Emotional trauma: Covers anxiety, depression, or psychological impacts from the accident.
Typical Settlement Ranges by Injury Type
Note: These figures represent averages and can vary substantially based on your specific medical costs, lost wages, injury severity, and impact on quality of life.
Who Can Be Held Liable for Ice-Related Injuries?
Multiple parties may share responsibility when someone slips on ice, depending on the property type and the accident’s circumstances. A slip and fall attorney can help identify which property owner is liable and whether an insurance company or liability insurance policy covers your damages.
Private Property Owners
Residential property owners maintain a duty to keep their premises reasonably safe for invited guests and visitors, including driveways, walkways, and steps. The duty owed varies based on visitor classification, with invitees receiving the highest level of care, while trespassers receive minimal protection.
Commercial Property Owners and Businesses
Business establishments bear heightened responsibility due to their public nature. They must maintain parking lots, entrances, and walkways free from hazardous conditions. The NYC Comptroller's Annual Claims Report reveals the City paid $53.5 million in sidewalk-related personal injury claims during Fiscal Year 2023, explicitly including snow and ice accidents. Learn how different types of falls affect liability in our detailed comparison.
Landlords and Apartment Complex Owners
Property managers must maintain common areas, including parking lots, walkways, and building entrances. Regardless of lease language, landlords can’t escape their duty to provide reasonably safe premises.
Municipal Liability for Public Property
Suing municipalities for slip and fall accidents on public sidewalks presents unique challenges. The "prior written notice" law typically requires proof that the city received actual written notice of the specific dangerous condition before the accident occurred.
How to Document and Prove Your Ice Injury Claim
Accurate documentation strengthens your case against a negligent property owner or their insurance company. A slip and fall attorney will help gather proof showing how the property owner failed to prevent the dangerous condition that caused your injury.
Document Everything Immediately
Photograph the accident scene from multiple angles, capturing the icy conditions, the surrounding area, the lighting, and any visible hazards. Take photos of your injuries and footwear. Note the temperature, weather conditions, and time of day.
Secure Witness Information
Obtain contact information for anyone who witnessed your fall or can attest to the dangerous conditions. Witness testimony often proves decisive when property owners dispute the hazard's existence or severity.
Obtain Medical Treatment
Seek immediate medical attention, even if injuries seem minor. Medical records documenting your injuries, treatment, and prognosis form the foundation of your compensation claim. Explain to healthcare providers that your injury resulted from slipping on ice.
Report the Incident
Notify the property owner or business in writing as soon as possible. Request copies of incident reports. For accidents on municipal property, file a Notice of Claim within 90 days—a mandatory prerequisite for lawsuit eligibility.
Preserve Evidence
Keep the shoes or boots you wore during the accident and photograph them. Save all medical bills, prescription receipts, and documentation of lost wages.
Contact an Attorney
Consult with our experienced slip and fall attorney as soon as possible. Our attorneys will protect your rights, handle insurance company communications, identify all liable parties, and ensure you meet critical filing deadlines. Legal representation significantly increases your chances of recovering fair compensation.
The Importance of Consulting a Slip and Fall Attorney
While minor slip and fall cases with clear liability and minimal injuries might be manageable on your own, most ice-related injury cases benefit significantly from legal representation. An attorney becomes essential when:
- Your injuries are serious or require ongoing medical treatment.
- Liability is disputed, or multiple parties may be responsible.
- The property owner or insurance company denies your claim.
- You're facing the "storm in progress" defense.
- Your accident occurred on municipal property, requiring specialized legal procedures and limited filing deadlines.
- You're uncertain about the full value of your claim.
Our exceptional slip and fall attorneys understand New York premises liability law, know how to counter common defenses, and can accurately value your claim to ensure you don't accept an inadequate settlement.
Protect Your Right to Compensation After an Ice-Related Fall
Time limits strictly govern slip and fall claims in New York. The statute of limitations provides three years to file lawsuits against private parties, but claims against municipalities require filing a Notice of Claim within just 90 days. Missing these deadlines permanently deprives you of your right to compensation.
The experienced personal injury attorneys at Fellows Hymowitz Rice bring decades of advanced knowledge and skill to ice-related slip and fall cases throughout New York State. Contact us today for your free legal consultation. We'll evaluate your case, explain your legal options, and fight to secure the compensation you deserve.
Discuss your case
Or Call Us 24/7
(845) 639-9300
Not Sure Who’s Responsible for Your Fall?
Determining liability after an ice-related accident can be confusing. Our legal team can review your case, explain your rights, and help you identify who may be held accountable.
